Before we enter a meeting, before dinner with friends, before we answer a colleague who asks, “How are you?” Many of us do a kind of work nobody sees. We edit ourselves.1
We do this for a number of reasons: we feel vulnerable, we want privacy, or simply, we’re just not sure how we feel. “I’m fine” may be true. But it’s rarely the whole answer. Before we respond, we begin calculating: How much should I share? Will this person understand? Do I have the strength to explain or even the time? Can this moment bear the complicated version?
In the first chapters of Genesis, the first question God ever asks a human being is: איכה — Ayeka? “Where are you?” God knows precisely where Adam is. Why would an all-knowing God ask where Adam is? The medieval commentator, Rashi, explains that God asks the question l’hi-kanes imo b’dvarim – in order to enter into a conversation with him. The Divine response to a human being in hiding is not a verdict. It’s a question. An invitation into a relationship.2
Adam begins with the truth: “I was afraid, and I hid.” He soon starts explaining and avoiding and blaming. We humans have been doing that ever since. For millennia, we have been learning how to reveal parts of ourselves, while deflecting and protecting ourselves at the same time.
Rosh Hashanah returns us to that first question. Before we can account for what we have done, we have to ask: Ayeka? Where am I? What am I carrying? And where have I begun to hide? Sometimes we hide because we are no longer sure what will happen to a relationship if they see all of us. So we edit. Sometimes that calculation is necessary. We do not owe every truth to every person.
When Belonging Is at Stake
But in the past few years, many of us have realized that we are no longer only deciding what to say. We are trying to figure out where we belong. If I say what I am feeling about antisemitism, will this friendship survive? Will people I think of as my people still want me if I tell them that I believe Israel has a right to self-determination?
We carry those questions into work. Into school. Into conversations with extended family and longtime friends. Sometimes even into conversations with other Jews. We are no longer sure which parts of us will be welcomed, which will require explanation, and which might cost us the relationship.
And that fear is not imagined. I hear it in the stories you have entrusted to me. Friendships have ended. Relationships have fractured. Communities and institutions we once relied upon no longer feel trustworthy. Many of us no longer feel at home in political or social communities that once felt natural.
Again and again, people have described this as a kind of homelessness. Not a literal homelessness, of course. But the disorientation of having people and communities around us, including communities and groups to which we once felt deeply connected, and no longer knowing where we can belong without hiding a part of ourselves. And this is not only a private ache. It is a Jewish communal problem. A community cannot become a home if belonging requires part of us to disappear.
This moment is especially disorienting because so much of what we are carrying refuses to fit into a simple binary. And still, implicitly and explicitly, we are told to choose. Are you afraid for Israelis, or are you concerned about Palestinians? Do you believe Israel has a right to defend itself, or do you believe its power must have limits? Many of us do not live on only one side of those choices. We may still believe in a group’s deepest values while feeling absolutely stunned and betrayed by what some of its leaders are saying or willing to tolerate. We may still want to vote with a political party this Fall and no longer feel at home among those who represent it. The problem is not a lack of conviction. It is that we are many things at once. And we no longer know where all of our convictions are allowed to belong together.
Jewish tradition does not imagine that a human being is internally simple.
Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik begins his Torah commentary with a strange fact: the Torah tells the story of human creation twice. In the first chapter of Genesis, Adam is created in the image of God and commanded to fill the earth and master it. In the second chapter, Adam is formed from dust, placed in a garden he did not create, and told to tend and protect it. Soloveitchik calls these two portraits Adam I and Adam II. Adam I creates, builds, and seeks mastery. Adam II seeks covenant, relationship, and meaning. They are not two different people, but two truths within every person. The Torah refuses to edit either one out. A morally serious life asks us to hold our power and our dependence, our agency and our obligations, within the same human life.3
Rabbi Soloveitchik’s insight helps us understand something about this moment. Our public life has become increasingly suspicious of complexity. Name one danger, and people assume you are indifferent to every other danger. Express one loyalty, and it is assumed you have surrendered your judgment. Acknowledge uncertainty, and some hear weakness. Change your mind, and it’s called betrayal. Say one thing, and someone thinks they know everything else you believe. So we calculate, again. Only now, belonging is at stake.
What makes this moment so exhausting is the demand that we resolve it by editing out part of ourselves.
Saying the Whole Sentence
I feel that pressure, too.
Before I speak publicly about Israel, America, or what frightens me about this moment, I think about who is listening. I imagine tomorrow morning’s inbox. Some of that caution is pastoral responsibility. I serve a community carrying many kinds of pain and many view points, and I do not want to be careless with any of it. But some of it is self-protection. So today, I want to try to say the whole sentence.
I love Israel. I believe the Jewish people have a right to self-determination and sovereignty. And I know in my bones and my own family’s history why Jewish safety and Jewish power matter and why Israel exists. The Second Intifada remains part of me. Rabbi Nichols and I lived in Jerusalem through twenty suicide bombings. And now the massacre and hostage-taking of October 7 have become a painful part of the terrible history of causing maximum bloodshed..
Hamas bears responsibility for October 7 and for the violence and repression it has inflicted on Palestinians and Israelis alike. And Israel remains responsible for how it exercises power and how it wages war. I grieve the staggering loss of Palestinian life and the devastation of Gaza. I am absolutely heartsick over unchecked settler violence, Jewish terrorism in the West Bank, and corrupt Israeli ministers who encourage expulsion and violence. These violate the values I believe Judaism and Israel must embody. And I understand, fully, why so many Jews are upset, frustrated and angry. I care about what kind of country Israel becomes and about the lives of everyone who lives there. Israel must be answerable for what it does, as every nation must be. That moral scrutiny is part of my commitment to Israel. But to me, criticism of Israel’s actions becomes something far different when criticism turns into a denial that the Jewish people have any right to self-determination.
We should not forget that we were once condemned as a people without a home; now some condemn us for having created a home in Israel and having found one here in the United States
Indeed, I am profoundly frightened by the normalization of antisemitism in movements and institutions I once trusted. I am frightened by the growing demand that Jews prove our commitment to humanity by disavowing who we are or sacrificing the parts of ourselves that bind us to Israel and the Jewish people. And I am frightened by political leaders who promise to defend Jews while weakening the institutions and pluralism on which Jewish safety and the safety of so many others depends. I worry about what this moment is doing to Jewish life here in Charlotte.
How are we handling the pressures that enter ordinary places: a child deciding whether to wear a Star of David or mention Israel at school; an adult rehearsing a sentence before speaking at work; a friend who recognizes antisemitism when it comes from the other political side but not from their own; the uncertainty of whether our neighbors will remain beside us when doing so becomes politically inconvenient. Here in Charlotte, too, people are looking for relationships in which they can be known without being reduced to a political position. Even as we protect Jewish life, danger cannot become its center. I want my children to inherit a tradition rooted in 3,500 years of history, strong enough to defend our people, morally serious enough to remain answerable to the suffering of others, and joyful enough to fill their lives with rituals, songs, prayer, holidays, memories, and hope.
Many truths. One rabbi.
From Heart to Speech
Your whole sentence may be different.
I’m not asking you to arrive at my conclusions. I am asking you to examine your own convictions honestly and notice what the fear of losing belonging has tempted you to leave out. The whole sentence is the account we can give of what we are carrying now, with enough humility to know that another person may help us see what we have missed. The sentences we edit are not always political. Sometimes what we cannot say is simply: I’m not okay.
A few years ago, Ana and I took our boys to see the band Imagine Dragons. The boys knew every lyric. There is something wonderful about standing with your children while they sing their hearts out. Between songs, the lead singer, Dan Reynolds, spoke about depression and a period when he did not know how he would make it through. Then he said, “Do you want to know what got me through?”
In4 that Charlotte arena, I had exactly one thought:
Please don’t say Jesus! Please don’t say Jesus! Please don’t say Jesus!
He didn’t. Then he said something like, “Find someone to talk to. Not everyone can afford therapy. But no one gets through life alone.” The band began their next song and the arena went back to singing along. But I was grateful my boys heard him say it. It is advice I have given a thousand times, just never to forty thousand people at once.
Jewish tradition understands that some truths have to be spoken. Maimonides teaches that teshuvah requires us to give words to what has taken shape in the heart.5 Bahya ibn Pakuda calls this work cheshbon hanefesh, an accounting of the soul: an honest examination of our lives – of what we are carrying and what life changes we need to make.6
Sometimes we edit not only what we reveal to others, but what we are willing to admit to ourselves. There are things we do not fully hear until we say them aloud. And a trusted person can sometimes hear what we cannot. And they ask the questions we have been avoiding. The internal accounting remains ours to do. The gift of relational interruption is that another person can help us see what we cannot see alone, creating a space between the story we have been living and what we choose to do next.
A Jewish Home for the Whole Person
So here is the practice I want to invite us into this year.
It is not about saying everything to everyone. It is about keeping necessary discretion from becoming disappearance. This moment has made belonging feel so uncertain. The first work is to remain recognizable to ourselves. The second is to risk being known in a relationship that has earned our trust. When honesty and connection survive together, we discover that belonging does not have to cost us a part of ourselves. And when we offer that same kind of presence to another person, we begin to build the Jewish home so many of us are searching for.
When you notice yourself editing, ask: What am I protecting? What might speaking cost me? Is this silence protecting something vulnerable, or is part of the truth beginning to disappear?
Tell the truth first to yourself. We can’t forget what might feel safer to leave out: The fear. The loyalty. The grief. The doubt. The conviction you have been reluctant to name.
Then, when wisdom and trust allow, bring what you have discovered to someone who knows you, has earned your trust, and can challenge you while staying in the relationship. Belonging does not demand identical choices. It asks us to remain in a relationship across them.
A Jewish home does not have to hold every claim without challenge or total agreement. But it must be able to hold a whole person – and it has for generations. We can’t let the pressures of the world push us to abandon the complexities within ourselves and with each other.
On this Rosh HaShanah, the question comes to us again:
Ayekah? Where are you?
At a moment when many of us feel a strange sense of homelessness, may we remain recognizable to ourselves.
May we have the courage to name what we are carrying and the wisdom to know where it can be spoken.
May we recognize the difference between a silence that protects something vulnerable and a silence that slowly erases something true.
May we find and create relationships in which we can speak honestly, be challenged, and remain connected.
And may we make a Jewish home at Temple Beth El and throughout Charlotte in which none of us has to disappear in order to belong.
- Thank you to my rabbinic thought partner, Rabbi Dara Frimmer, writing coach, Michele Lowe, my sister-in-law, Julia Bonnheim, and wife, Ana Bonnheim for their valuable insights, edits and suggestions. ↩
- Rashi on Genesis 3:9 says that the question is an invitation for a conversation.
איכה — יודע היה היכן הוא, אלא ליכנס עמו בדברים. ↩ - Joseph B. Soloveitchik, The Lonely Man of Faith (New York: Image Books/Doubleday, 2006), 9–10, 80–87. Soloveitchik interprets the two creation accounts in Genesis as portraying two divinely intended dimensions within every human being: Adam I, majestic and creative, and Adam II, humble and covenantal. He argues that neither may be rejected and that human beings must live with the continuing tension between them. The application of this teaching to contemporary political polarization—and to the pressure to suppress convictions that do not fit neatly within one ideological camp—is my own. ↩
- After delivering this sermon, I learned that during a 2025 performance in Milan, Dan Reynolds waved a Palestinian flag that had been thrown onto the stage. I was unaware of that incident when I wrote and delivered these remarks, and I would have wanted to know about it before deciding whether to use him as an example.
I referenced Reynolds for one specific reason: a brief reflection I heard him offer about depression, human connection, and the importance of reaching out to another person in times of struggle. I believed then, and still believe, that particular insight contains an important truth.
I have also since learned that Reynolds’s public record is more complicated than the flag incident alone might suggest. Imagine Dragons performed in Tel Aviv in 2023 despite calls to boycott Israel, and Reynolds later said that he did not regret performing there, explaining that he did not believe audiences should be held responsible for the actions of their governments. I have found no accompanying statement from Reynolds explaining the political meaning he intended by displaying the Palestinian flag.
None of this requires agreement with Reynolds or with that gesture. It does reinforce a distinction that matters to me: citing a particular insight is not the same as endorsing everything a person believes or does.
One of this sermon’s central themes is how quickly we can move from an event to a conclusion about another person’s motives, loyalties, or character. Accountability requires us to take new information seriously. It does not require us to let a single act become the whole story of a person.
I have therefore left the sermon itself unchanged and added this note because the additional context belongs alongside the argument rather than replacing it. ↩
- Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Hilchot Teshuvah 2:2. After describing teshuvah as leaving the wrongdoing, regretting it, and resolving internally not to return to it, Rambam concludes:
וצריך להתודות בשפתיו ולומר עניינות אלו שגמר בלבו
“S/He must confess with his lips and give voice to these matters that he resolved in his heart.” Or, said another way, “move it from heart to speech.” ↩ - Baḥya ibn Paquda, Duties of the Heart, Gate 8, “The Gate of Self-Accounting,” ch. 1. ↩