The Strange Grammar of “We”
Yom Kippur has strange grammar. Again and again we confess: Ashamnu, Bagadnu, Gazalnu, Dibarnu Dofi… Even before we translate the words, we hear the ending. “nu” In Hebrew, the suffix, –nu means we. We have betrayed. We have spoken cruelly. We have hardened our hearts. By the end of the alphabetical confession, we have implicated ourselves in nearly every human failure for which the Hebrew language could find a letter.2
Some of those failures I recognize immediately. Others make me think: I didn’t do that. I barely had enough time to do the things I actually did. Surely that one belongs to someone else. And I promise you from up here on the bimah, I am not assigning likely candidates!
Beyond Guilt
Our machzor gathers every failure into the first-person plural and asks us to claim them all. Wait—to claim them all? And that creates a problem, because Yom Kippur is supposed to be a day of truth. Surely, it would not ask us to confess falsely. Yom Kippur’s “we” widens the accounting: I begin with what I did. Then the prayer asks what happened among all of us? And even more importantly: what does that ask of me now?
Innocence may answer the question of guilt. It does not settle the question of responsibility. This is the moral force of the first-person plural: another person’s suffering can become my responsibility without being my fault.3
My brother, who is my best friend, and I joke about Jewish guilt all the time. I am certain that mine is inherited. His, from my perspective, is entirely evidence-based. Our tradition gives guilt somewhere to go: it’s called accountability. Long before the thousand-page machzor gave us Ashamnu, Torah placed that accountability inside the covenant we read this morning.
Kulchem: All of You
Atem nitzavim hayom kulchem lifnei Adonai Eloheichem. “You stand this day, all of you, before Adonai your God.”4 Then Torah names the people standing there: leaders, laborers, elders, children, and strangers. Their power and experiences differ. Yet, one word brings them into covenant, together: Kulchem. All of you. Their differences remain. Their future is bound together.
The covenant also includes “those who are not with us here this day,” whom the medieval commentator, Rashi, understands as future generations.5 And with that, kulchem crosses time. “All of you” includes every Jewish generation still to come. That is either breathtakingly aspirational or a little chutzpadik. I didn’t write it. You can take it up with Moses and Rashi. The Torah makes a claim: people we will never meet already have a stake in the Jewish life we are building now.
The rabbis gave this responsibility a name: Kol Yisrael arevim zeh bazeh. All Israel are responsible for one another.6 That obligation, in Hebrew, is called arevut. Say it with me: arevut. It means that another Jewish life can make a claim on ours. And that we have a stake in whether other Jews can survive and flourish. 7 That mutual reliance, of Jews showing up for one another, carried Jewish life across centuries and oceans. The first enduring Jewish community in what became the United States survived because Jews across an ocean made its future their concern.
A Web of Obligation
In 1654, after Portugal retook Dutch Brazil and the threat of the Inquisition returned, twenty-three Sephardic Jews reached New Amsterdam, now known as New York. Governor Peter Stuyvesant tried to expel them. But Jews across the ocean in Amsterdam, that is, THE AMSTERDAM, intervened on their behalf. And the Dutch West India Company allowed the Jewish population to stay, provided that “their own nation” took care of the poor. The first enduring Jewish community in what became the United States survived because Jews across an ocean made their future their concern, and here in America, we began taking responsibility for one another.8
And all of that was part of a much older practice of arevut, of mutual responsibility. Across the diaspora, Jews raised ransoms for captives they would never meet. A local chevra kaddisha, Jewish burial society, buried those who died without family or means. We would give tzedakah, giving what we have to those in need. That web of obligation helped a scattered people remain a people.9 That instinct remains. We practice it here.
After Hurricane Helene left Beth HaTephila in Asheville without water, internet, or working systems, Temple Beth El raised $125,000 and helped both members of their community and the synagogue keep operating. When Asheville Jews could not gather in their own synagogue for the High Holy Days, we opened our doors and our homes to them.10 After an arsonist badly damaged Beth Israel in Jackson, Mississippi, and destroyed two Torah scrolls, many of you donated funds that are helping the congregation rebuild.11
Each time, Jews beyond this building needed something within our reach. We answered. That is arevut. That is mutual responsibility. We don’t know them. But we take care of them.
And here is why this is important: Antisemitism and major events, appropriately, force much of our attention toward danger and alleviating pain.
After a hurricane or an arson attack, the needs that announce themselves are as clear as day. And we know how, as a Jewish community, to respond.
Arevut in Ordinary Life
But what we are less good at is seeing the needs of one another on a regular day. Most days, the need is quiet enough to miss. Someone receives a diagnosis and does not know whom to call. An older member stops coming because driving after dark no longer feels safe. Weeks after shiva, a mourner’s phone stops ringing. A newcomer has no Shabbat table with which to celebrate. Forty minutes away, a Jewish family wonders how to give its children the Jewish education they want. Someone with something to give is still waiting to be asked. These are daily needs that people in our community have, and that we are less good at seeing.
And in a world that once again feels exceptionally dangerous to be Jewish, I am deeply aware of something that history has taught us again and again: No one will take responsibility for the Jewish people quite like the Jewish people. That work, that responsibility, is ours.
And I want you to understand why this matters so deeply to me as your rabbi. When I look at the Jewish community around us, I do not see members close by and Jews farther away. I see people for whom we bear responsibility. I cannot promise to know every need. But I feel responsible for building a community in which fewer Jews have to carry their lives alone, especially right now. I want the child who is the only Jew in her school, the family forty minutes away, and the person sitting in this sanctuary who has not yet found their people to know the same thing: You are not alone. You are part of us. And we are responsible for one another.
That responsibility for Jews in Charlotte already reaches farther than I think many of us realize. When this building was built in 1992, most of our membership lived in three ZIP codes. Today, Temple Beth El members live in seventy ZIP codes, and our Religious School students attend more than ninety schools. They are often the only Jewish kids in their classes, their grades, or their whole school. But behind those numbers are families wondering how distance will shape the Jewish lives of their children or whether they will have clergy available to them in times of need. Jewish families in Gaston County, Lake Norman, and Fort Mill already stand within our Temple covenant. We have many, many members driving here from these areas. We know that Jewish life must reach Jews where they live. In a time of increasing isolation, we need to show up and build a stronger web of regional Judaism that supports the care and wellbeing of one another. Arevut, responsibility for one another, means that distance should not become isolation. But geography raises a larger question: How wide is the circle of people for whom we feel responsible? Because Jewish difference is not only about where we live.
The Jewish people have never had one face, one background, or one way of living. Contrary to the antisemitic narrative that Jews are all European, among us are Black and Persian and African and Indian and Hispanic and Asian Jews, Jews by choice, members of interfaith families, immigrants, secular Jews, and Jews whose backgrounds and observance may be unfamiliar to us. Torah gathers all of us into one word: Kulchem. In Charlottean: all y’all. Jewish pluralism asks us not to erase those differences, but to remain responsible for one another across them.
Temple Beth El brings our commitments proudly. Women and LGBTQ Jews lead here. Jews by choice need no asterisk. Interfaith families belong without reservation, and we are grateful to non-Jewish parents who help pass Torah to Jewish children. These commitments have widened who can belong and lead across Jewish life. And yet, I want you to understand that my commitment to Jewish pluralism also means this:
I can pray in an egalitarian sanctuary, where the women’s section, as far as I’m concerned, seems to be right here on the bimah, and care that an Orthodox family can find a minyan that reflects their religious preferences and kosher food. I can pray differently from the rabbis of Temple Israel or Or HaTorah and care deeply that their congregations flourish.
Their Jewish home matters even when it is not mine.
That is arevut, and it is one of the things I love about the culture we have created in Charlotte and Shalom Park.
Making a Home for One Another
On Rosh HaShanah, I spoke about the strange sense of homelessness many Jews feel right now.12
Yom Kippur asks what we will build in response. It asks us to make a home for one another. And that means something demanding: We are responsible for one another. For noticing when someone is missing. For making room when someone is new. For reaching toward someone who is alone. For allowing ourselves to be known when we are the ones who need help. My belonging is not only about whether this community is here for me. It is also about whether someone else experiences this community as home because I am here.
Belonging is something we receive, and something we help create.
We have seen how quickly people give when a crisis becomes visible. And that is beautiful. On an ordinary Tuesday, many of us feel less certain.
Modern life has made independence look like success, and convenience feel almost like a virtue.
Dinner arrives at the door without our speaking to the person who brought it. A professional handles the crisis. An algorithm learns our preferences and arranges more and more of the world around them. Social media turns even friendship toward presentation: how does my life appear to everyone else? None of these things is terrible in itself. Much of it makes life genuinely easier. But taken together, they are teaching us something about what a life is supposed to be: self-sufficient, personalized, efficient, and increasingly free of claims from other people.
And I wonder whether we have mistaken needing less from one another for needing one another less. We can spend an entire day surrounded by the labor of other human beings without learning their names. We can receive what we need without relationship. We can arrange more and more of life around our preferences without having to negotiate with another person’s. And we can become so accustomed to that arrangement that we begin to expect community to work the same way.
Does it meet my needs? Does it reflect my preferences? Is it convenient? Am I getting what I came for?
When it disappoints us, we can leave instead of having a conversation. When something needs doing, we can assume someone else has been hired to do it. When someone disappears, we can assume someone else will notice.
Those habits follow us into Jewish life. We can participate for years and remain strangers. We can receive what a community offers without becoming responsible for anyone within it.
And then we wonder why belonging feels so elusive. Because belonging is almost the opposite of the world I have just described. It is not personalized. It is not always efficient. It cannot be delivered to the door. Belonging begins when our lives make claims upon one another. When someone notices we are missing. When someone needs the ride. When someone is waiting because we said we would come. That is when a place stops being something we use and becomes something to which we belong.
And in an age when we are questioning where we, as Jews, belong—where we can tell our whole truth—I am being straightforward when I tell you: that belonging comes about when two sentences are simultaneously true:
I can count on someone here.
Someone here can count on me.
Recently, I heard about a member of Temple Beth El who needed an outpatient procedure. She had no one to drive her. Her family lives elsewhere. Another member who had learned beside her in an adult education class and become her friend offered to help. He drove her, waited through the procedure, and brought her home. Her need rearranged his Tuesday. That is covenant on a human scale.
I know that some of you already carry more than your share. At home and in this community, you are the person people call first. You have said yes and shown up so often that the rest of us may have forgotten that every yes costs you something. And you may be thinking: Please, for the love of God, Rabbi, find someone else. Our community that depends on you must care for you, too. A healthy community moves the weight from shoulder to shoulder. Some of us need relief. And at this moment, more of us need the belonging that is created through a responsibility with our name on it.
I know that showing up regularly may be one of Judaism’s least glamorous spiritual practices. Once the sanctuary empties and the emotion of this day passes, covenant usually looks like a regular old Tuesday.
We call, teach, drive, or make room at a table. We return when we said we would. Then we return again and again.
Over time, we become part of one another’s lives.
This is how a community becomes a home. And if we feel that strange sense of Jewish homelessness these days, perhaps the answer is not only to search for where we belong. It is to show up, take responsibility, become people others can count on, and help build the home we are searching for.
This is “We”: What Belonging Requires
When we say Ashamnu, listen for the final syllable.
Nu.
We.
Atem nitzavim hayom kulchem.
All of us are standing here.
Kol Yisrael arevim zeh bazeh.
We are responsible for one another.
Across centuries of danger and distance, Jews kept finding one another. Most of their names are lost to history. Their promises are still here, in the Torah we still carry and argue over and at tables where a stranger can become family.
That responsibility has reached us.
We did not build the Jewish world we inherited. But we are responsible for what happens within it now, and for what it becomes. The question is not only what Jewish life gives us. It is what Jewish life becomes because of how we choose to live within it.
So Yom Kippur asks: Who will belong because we were here?
Jewish life in Charlotte will be shaped by what we are willing to give it. So I am asking every one of us to make one concrete commitment to Jewish life this year.
Volunteer—and keep showing up. Learn with us. Help teach our children. Welcome a newcomer. Call someone who is alone. Visit someone in the hospital. Make a contribution that allows another person to learn, worship, celebrate, or receive care.
Choose one promise. Attach it to a day. Put it on your calendar or in your budget of time, energy, and resources. And if you do not know where you are needed, ask us. We will help you find your part.
Tonight the gates will close. Tuesday will come. Quite literally, tomorrow. And the words we have said here will have to leave this room with us.
“We” is an easy word to say in a sanctuary. It is a much more beautiful thing to make real. Because “we” means that our lives can matter beyond ourselves. We can matter to people we know. We can matter to people we will never know. And the way we live now can shape a world we will never see.
Years from now, a Jewish child we will never meet will inherit a Jewish world shaped by us. They will grow up knowing that there is a Jewish community for them—a place to learn, to pray, to question, to celebrate, to belong.
And long before then, someone already among us will know what kind of “we” we chose to become.
This is one of the great promises of Jewish life: that separate human beings can become responsible for one another, can make a home together, and can carry something precious farther than any one of us could imagine.
May the “we” of our prayers become the way we live.
G’mar chatimah tovah — may each of us be inscribed in the Book of Life.
Notes
- Thank you to my rabbinic thought partner, Rabbi Dara Frimmer, my writing coach Michele Lowe, and the sage editing wisdom of my sister-in-law, Julia Bonnheim and wife, Ana Bonnheim.
- Mishkan HaNefesh: Machzor for the Days of Awe—Yom Kippur, ed. Edwin C. Goldberg et al. (New York: Central Conference of American Rabbis, 2015), [insert the page used in Temple Beth El’s edition], Vidui/Ashamnu: אָשַׁמְנוּ, בָּגַדְנוּ, גָּזַלְנוּ, דִּבַּרְנוּ דֹּפִי . . . In these verbal forms, the suffix ־נוּ is the first-person common-plural ending, “we.” The confession follows the Hebrew alphabet.
- Deuteronomy 21:1–9 offers a biblical precedent for distinguishing guilt from communal responsibility. When a murdered traveler is found and the killer is unknown, the elders declare, “Our hands did not shed this blood, nor did our eyes see it done” (Deuteronomy 21:7). The Mishnah asks whether anyone could seriously suspect the elders of murder and explains that they are instead accounting for whether the traveler was allowed to leave their community without food or accompaniment. The elders may be innocent of the killing while still answerable for the conditions in which the victim was left vulnerable. See Mishnah Sotah 9:6 and Babylonian Talmud, Sotah 45b. Also see: Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 54b “Whoever is able to protest wrongdoing within their household and does not is held accountable for the household; one able to do so within the city is held accountable for the city; one whose influence reaches the whole world is held accountable for the whole world.” The passage speaks specifically about the capacity to protest wrongdoing; Responsibility follows effective reach, to other forms of assistance.
- Deuteronomy 29:9–10:
- Deuteronomy 29:13–14 & Babylonian Talmud, Shevuot 39a, interpreting Deuteronomy 29:14: Also see Rashi on Deuteronomy 29:14.
- Babylonian Talmud, Shavuot 29a:21-22
- Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 54b “Whoever is able to protest wrongdoing within their household and does not is held accountable for the household; one able to do so within the city is held accountable for the city; one whose influence reaches the whole world is held accountable for the whole world.” The passage speaks specifically about the capacity to protest wrongdoing; Responsibility follows effective reach, to other forms of assistance.
- Hasia R. Diner, The Jews of the United States, 1654 to 2000 (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2004), 13–15; “Petition of the Jewish Nation,” January 1655, trans. Samuel Oppenheim, Historical Society of Pennsylvania, Am.226; Directors of the Dutch West India Company at Amsterdam to Peter Stuyvesant and the Council of New Netherland, April 26, 1655, New York State Archives, Dutch Colonial Administrative Correspondence, series A1810-78, vol. 12, document 18.
- Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Gifts to the Poor 8:1. On the communal appeals and networks for redeeming captives documented in the Cairo Geniza, see Mark R. Cohen, Poverty and Charity in the Jewish Community of Medieval Egypt (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2005), 109–129; see also the National Library of Israel, “The Story of a Nation That Redeems Its Captives.”
- Hurricane Relief Efforts Update,” Temple Beth El, November 20, 2024 and updated accounting in the months that followed.
- Sophie Bates and Kendria LaFleur, “Mississippi Synagogue Congregant Shares Story of 1967 Ku Klux Klan Bombing,”Associated Press, January 14, 2026; Temple Beth El, “Standing Together as a Jewish Community,” January 13, 2026; United States Department of Justice, “Mississippi Man Indicted for Arson of Beth Israel Synagogue and the Goldring/Woldenberg Institute of Southern Jewish Life,” February 12, 2026, updated July 22, 2026.
- Rabbi Asher Knight, “A Strange Kind of Homelessness,” Rosh HaShanah Morning 5787/2026, Temple Beth El, Charlotte, North Carolina.