I often find myself making a disclaimer when someone asks me a question about Judaism: if they came to hear one “right” answer, they will leave disappointed. Judaism, I explain, rarely gives an easy answer, and for that matter, rarely gives a single answer. After all, we are the Children of Israel, and Israel, Yisrael, means to wrestle or struggle with God. Asking questions, bringing challenges, seeking to understand why the world works the way it does…these are fundamentally Jewish actions. In its emphasis on asking questions and considering a myriad of possibilities, our Judaism can help bring meaning to our complicated lives.
If we look at the origin story of the name Yisrael, we are drawn back into a dark time in the life of our patriarch Jacob. Nervous about a reunion with his brother Esau, Jacob sends his wives and children across the river and camps alone. In the middle of the night he wrestles with an unknown being, perhaps an angel or messenger from God, perhaps his own conscience. As dawn breaks, the being wrenches Jacob’s hip and asks to be released. Jacob, however, demands a blessing before he lets go. The blessing he receives is his new name, Israel.
How is this new name a blessing? The blessing comes, I believe, through what the name conveys: an ability to face challenging times and come out the other side with new insights about oneself, new skills with which to confront future challenges, and new ways to be a blessing. Rabbi Jonathan Sacks said of the Jewish people, referencing this episode in the Torah, “Their darkest nights have always been preludes to their most creative dawns.” The Jewish people have been through countless tragedies over thousands of years, and yet we are still here: living our lives, creating community, and making a difference.
But Jacob’s story provides inspiration not just for the Jewish people as a whole, but for each of us as individuals. If we reflect on this story as the experience of a single man, we see that Jacob experienced a great challenge and did not emerge unscathed – his hip was wrenched and he walked away with a limp. But Jacob also walked away with a transformed identity and a blessing. He walked away wounded, altered forever, but he walked away as the starting point of an entire people. He carried the blessing and the limp, side by side.
Sitting in this sanctuary tonight, we are surrounded by people who, over the past year, have, like Jacob, wrestled with unknown beings – who have faced, or are facing, dark nights with uncertain outcomes. Some of us are struggling with a health crisis, some are grieving a loss; some of us are burdened by debt, some are survivors of violence. Not one of us has lived a year without some kind of challenge or hardship. What our Judaism invites us to do is to be like Jacob – to be in the darkness, to be changed by it, to come through the darkness, and maybe to find blessings alongside the hurt. We are not meant to forget our hardships or pretend they didn’t leave scars on our souls. But with time, we hope to find a way to keep living, to see that darkness and light, sorrow and joy, grief and hope can exist alongside each other.
Often, when we confront a challenge or experience a trauma, we turn to the “whys?” We ask why this happened, why it happened to us, and why God, or the world, didn’t protect us. We could mine our sacred texts for answers, and believe me, the ancient rabbis thought a lot about why bad things happen. Their answers may infuriate you or confuse you, but I assure you, none of them will be truly satisfying. And more importantly, none of them will eliminate the need to face the challenge, confront the source of pain, or survive the hardship. We don’t believe that an illness is some kind of divine punishment, or that a war was caused specifically to teach us some greater lesson. Those kinds of answers don’t provide much comfort and can even add to our pain. We need to shift our language and our questions. Instead of saying that the hardship was created in order for us to learn, we need to ask, now that we are experiencing this hardship, what spiritual tools do we have to face it, and over time, what might we learn?
Judaism provides us with ways to respond. According to Alan Morinis, author of the book Everyday Holiness, Judaism is not meant to help us “reach an enlightened state in which all the questions and conundrums of life are unknotted with finality.” Instead, Judaism can help us “become much more skilled at the processes of living.” Our tradition teaches us in Unataneh Tokef, a prayer we will recite again tomorrow, we cannot choose the challenges on our path, but we can choose how we live with them and through them.
To become more skilled at living, we need to be willing to accept and acknowledge the challenges as they come. We need to be willing to step into the discomfort that life brings. In society today, we spend a lot of time trying to avoid all types of discomfort. We filter where we go, who we see, what we read… all in an attempt to shield ourselves or our loved ones from pain, guilt, conflict, and disappointment. But avoidance usually only serves to delay the discomfort or push the conflict down the road. Every experience is a part of shaping who we are, whether we asked for it or not. And if we choose presence over avoidance, and courage over comfort, we may discover possibilities for connection, compassion, or growth that we could not see or realize before.
When we let ourselves be in the discomfort, acknowledge that an experience is painful, frightening, or confusing, we give ourselves room to express our feelings and ultimately discover our own strength. The person sitting on the couch in my office who apologizes for her tears. There is no need to apologize. An empty tissue box is a sign that someone acknowledged their suffering and is reaching for connection.
When we let ourselves be in the discomfort, and we realize that we can’t do it all, we have the chance to identify what is most dear to our hearts. We have the chance to feel gratitude for what truly matters in our lives and move forward with a clearer sense of what we value. The person who starts a new career following an illness because his exhaustion following treatment helped define how he wants to spend his limited time.
When we let ourselves be in the discomfort, we can find community. Because when we have the courage to let our brokenness show, we find that there are others around us who have their own kind of brokenness. No one, even those struggling with the same illness or living through the same trauma, has the same exact experience as another person. But when we acknowledge that we are unmoored, we allow others to share their stories and we can hold on to one another.
During Shabbat services we sing the words of the Mi Sheberach, a prayer for healing written by renowned Jewish musician Debbie Friedman. If you are like me, you have sung this melody so many times that you can sing the words and let your mind wander to the faces of the people in your life who are in need of healing. I love the freedom that familiar words give to us, but for just a moment, I want to really focus our attention on the final line of the first verse. We pray to God to “Help us find the courage to make our lives a blessing.” This line doesn’t appear at first to be about healing. But in this line, I hear an invitation to turn the difficulties of our lives into blessings. We seek courage because stepping into our discomfort is hard and allowing our pain to be a blessing to ourselves or someone else, that leaves us vulnerable.
Debbie Friedman once shared, “It is a strange thing that pain creates beauty and potential for healing….The willingness to both offer and receive blessings of healing and wellbeing allows one who is wounded to transform and unravel the pain.” Asking God to grant us courage is about healing because imagining that our difficulty can some day become a blessing gives us hope and moves us forward. This type of healing is different than a cure. Depending on the situation we are facing, we may not be able to return to our original state of being. But this type of healing comes when we allow ourselves to find a new normal, when we allow the pain to exist alongside the hope; when we integrate our experiences into a vision of ourselves moving forward.
It is important to note that while it can be helpful to confront our discomfort, it is also possible to get stuck in it. We can become mired in despair when our discomfort and pain are not accompanied by glimpses of hope and transformation. Sometimes that happens when our pain is around an issue largely out of our control – anguish over a moral rupture in our society’s values, or heartache over the consequences of war and violence around the world. We can allow ourselves to be in the discomfort – to grieve, advocate, witness or act – while recognizing the limits of our control and seeking help if our despair becomes too heavy to carry alone.
When we have more agency over the source of our discomfort, that is when we can lean in: we can examine the pain of a damaged relationship with a friend, consider the lasting impacts of a trauma we experienced, or acknowledge the disappointment of a commitment we didn’t keep with ourselves. This type of reflection is the spiritual work of these Days of Awe. Asking ourselves, are there actions I can take that can shift my feelings of despair or repair something that has broken?
Over the summer I read a fictional story that follows multiple generations of a family living through different wars in Ukraine: one generation lives through occupation by Tzarist
Russia, another through World War II, and one is living in the ongoing conflict in Ukraine today.
In the narrative about the present time, the main character, Ana, starts corresponding with Maksim, a Ukrainian soldier on the frontlines. They form a deep relationship before even meeting in person, sharing their fears about the war with one another. In one email from the front, Maksim quotes a poem:
Through all my tears I still shall laugh,
Sing songs despite my troubles;
Have hope despite all odds,
I want to live! Away, you sorrowful thoughts!
I read the verse over and over and then pinned it in my Kindle App. I wondered, did the author of the book make this poem up, or is it a real poem. I came to discover that it is a famous poem by Ukrainian poet Lesya Ukrainka. It felt so appropriate in the story, and yet she didn’t write it during a time of war. She wrote the poem about her own struggle with tuberculosis. She wrote about illness, yet it spoke to a fictional character under bombardment in a war zone and to a rabbi thinking about how we support people in crisis.
What I hear in Ukrainka’s words is that elusive balance between hope and despair. She does not deny the pain, but simultaneously, makes room for blessings and possibilities. She writes in a later verse, “On this poor, indigent ground I shall sow flowers of flowing colors; I shall sow flowers even amidst the frost, and water them with my bitter tears.” Ukrainka is living out Debbie Friedman’s words: She is wounded but works to transform and unravel her pain, and to allow her experience to lift up the pain of others.
In Psalm 126 we read, “Those who sow in tears, will reap in joy.” What I find most powerful about this verse is the agricultural imagery of the verbs. Sowing and reaping are not light tasks. This is not a simple promise that once you experience difficulties you will automatically experience joy. Instead, these words communicate that it takes hard work to move through difficult times and hard work to lift ourselves up to moments of joy. The hope contained within these words is not blind optimism, but wise counsel: the knowledge that out of struggle can come hope.
A Jewish day begins when the sun goes down, when darkness settles over the world. And a Jewish month begins at the darkest point of the lunar cycle – at the moment of the new moon when the sky is illuminated by only the tiniest sliver of light. But standing in the darkness, we know that the light will grow. We know that out of darkness comes the promise of light.
In the coming year, as a community and as individuals, we will each wrestle with unknown beings – we will each face new challenges, large and small. May we have the courage to face them and feel them, may we have the courage to seek and offer help, may we have the courage to be changed by our struggles, and may we have the courage to make our lives a blessing.
G’mar Chatimah Tovah.