From Isolation to Invitation: Weaving a Stronger Social Fabric

Last spring, Nicole Sidman, our Director of Congregational Life, and I arrived at an interfaith reproductive rights conference eager to learn, to connect, and to find common ground with faith leaders from across the country. But almost immediately, the welcome we expected dissolved into something colder, even hostile. Again and again, subtle signals made it clear: we were not welcome participants, but outsiders.

This truth became unavoidable when a faith leader offered blessings for a long list of groups—and made sure to add a blessing for the “anti-Zionist Jews who are standing up to Israel.” In an instant, the conference’s lofty claims of inclusivity rang hollow. Jews were welcome—but not all Jews, only the “right” kinds.

My body tensed and my heart raced. Beside me, Nicole bristled with anger. She stood up, leaned toward me, and whispered, “We don’t need this. Let’s go.” I froze in fear. Nicole bolted with rage.

We can all think of a moment when we felt threatened or afraid, and responded in a similar manner. These responses aren’t just emotional; they are physiological. For millennia, humans have relied on three basic reactions to threat: fight, flight, or freeze. These instincts kept our ancestors alive on the savannah — and they echo through our tradition as well.

When faced with danger, some biblical figures fought: David confronted Goliath head-on; Esther risked her life by approaching King Achashverosh. Others fled: Jacob escaped Esau’s wrath, Moses ran away from Egypt after killing the taskmaster. Still others froze: Aaron gave in and let the Israelites build the Golden Calf, Jonah slept below deck as the storms raged on.

Today, our fight-flight-freeze response is triggered not by lions or invading armies, but by hateful posts, offhand comments, and public confrontations. Many of us feel ourselves pulled into those same instincts as antisemitism and political violence move from headlines into our daily lives. In the past year, 56% of American Jews report altering their behavior out of fear of antisemitism — avoiding Jewish symbols, refraining from posting online, or steering clear of public spaces.1 Surveys show most of us now avoid talking politics with people who disagree with us, and many say it feels stressful or even dangerous to share our true opinions. Fear has replaced dialogue, leaving us silent, withdrawn, and suspicious instead of curious and connected.

And so, we react. We may fight — clench our jaws, argue back, take to the comments section or to the street. We may flee — block the account, not speak up when we hear problematic language, or step back from the world. We may freeze — numb out, dissociate, binge shows or scroll endlessly to escape.

But our tradition doesn’t let the story end with that initial response of fight, flight or freeze. Jacob and Esau reconcile in an emotional reunion. Moses returns to Egypt to set his people free. Jonah finally heeds God’s call. Again and again, God calls us back out of hiding and back into courage and community.

And while Nicole and I reacted viscerally in that moment, we refused to stay stuck in fight, flight, or freeze. We did ultimately leave the conference early—but we didn’t just walk away. We gathered ourselves, reached out to the organizers, and engaged in an honest, constructive conversation about our experience. In doing so, we reclaimed our agency, turning a moment of fear and anger into an opening for dialogue, learning and connection.

Lately I’ve noticed how deeply our society — both within the Jewish community and beyond — has become trapped in fight, flight, and freeze. We are told we must fight back against antisemitism, crush our political opponents, build higher walls, and summon more police to guard our institutions. We retreat into digital echo chambers and literal fortified spaces, seeking safety but finding only isolation. We hunker down in our caves, convinced that retreat will protect us, yet feeling the ache of separation and the slow erosion of our communal life.

Tonight, I’m calling us to a harder, holier task: to recognize our fear and step past it. To loosen our grip, to open our hands, to reach out first. Not to lock ourselves away, but to open the door. Not to battle, but to break bread. Not to retreat into silence, but to enter into real conversation, seeking to understand and to be understood.

I experienced this myself on an interfaith alternative spring break trip in college. Our group included Jews of multiple denominations, Lutherans, Mormons, Muslims, Hindus, and Buddhists. By day, we built houses with Habitat for Humanity under the hot Florida sun; by night, we had long, searching conversations about our faiths. We didn’t avoid hard topics—reproductive rights, LGBTQ+ inclusion, theological differences—but the trust we built swinging hammers together gave us the courage to listen and to be honest. We saw one another as full human beings, not just a single issue or label. We left those conversations not with mutual agreement, but with mutual respect.

In On Repentance and Repair, Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg tells story of Derek Black, the heir to a prominent white-supremacist family.2 When his classmates discovered his hidden identity at the New College of Florida, he was shunned. But one student, Matthew Stevenson—an Orthodox Jew—took a risk. Instead of cutting him off, Matthew invited Derek to Shabbat dinner. Derek came once, then again and again. Week after week, Matthew and his friends welcomed Derek to their table, modeling a different way of being. Over time, those dinners broke through Derek’s defenses. He renounced white nationalism, left his family’s movement, and began working against the ideology he once embodied. Ruttenberg points to this story as a profound example of the power of hospitality to transform hatred into healing.

Our people have always known this power. Abraham and Sarah welcomed three strangers into their tent and received angels instead. The Torah commands, “You shall love the stranger, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt.” Our prophets envisioned a day when all nations would stream to God’s house of prayer. Again and again, Jewish tradition insists that the antidote to fear is hospitality, that the way through division is relationship, that the holiest act is to widen the circle of belonging.

So what might it mean for us, here at Temple Beth El, to choose hospitality over hostility? How can we weave a stronger social fabric, not just within our walls but across Charlotte?

First, in our synagogue: Come to services, come to classes, come to programs — not just for yourself, but to make this a place where others are seen and known. Show up not only to take in, but to extend out. Greet someone you don’t know. Learn a new name. Offer a blessing, a hand, a smile. Hospitality begins with presence.

Second, in Jewish community: Bring friends, neighbors, and colleagues into Jewish life, help demystify our traditions, and discover new connections. And don’t stop there—consider visiting their congregation or community, too. Mutual hospitality is powerful.

Third, in the community: Help us reach out to churches, schools, and organizations. Invite them to tour our synagogue, learn about Jewish values and holidays, and engage in real dialogue.

Fourth, at home: Open your table and your heart. Host a Shabbat dinner for friends, neighbors, or colleagues who aren’t Jewish. We’ll provide everything you need—blessings, conversation prompts, and tips to make everyone feel welcome.

This might feel like a small response to an overwhelming challenge. What difference could a few Shabbat dinners make? Yet consider this: there are more than 3,000 churches in greater Charlotte, but only a handful of synagogues — only a few of which are large enough to have full-time clergy. Jews make up just .03% of the greater Charlotte population.3

In other words, most people have never experienced Jewish life up close. Your colleagues, neighbors, and acquaintances may know you’re Jewish but have little sense of what that means — what we believe, how we celebrate, or the values we live by. That’s why every Shabbat invitation matters.

Imagine the collective power: if every household in our congregation hosted just one Shabbat dinner this year, we could create hundreds of tables of learning, friendship, and understanding. Week after week, this simple practice could grow into our culture, our habit — a living gift of openheartedness we offer to our community.

Share Shabbat is our invitation to reclaim Shabbat not only as a spiritual practice but as a practice of radical welcome. In a world that often pushes us to withdraw, and in a moment when fear can feel like the safest response, we are choosing something different. We are choosing agency. We are choosing courage. We are choosing to open our doors, set our tables, cook our meals, and share who we are with our neighbors. Through Share Shabbat we can build and deepen relationships — weaving a stronger, more vibrant social fabric that extends beyond our walls.

So I encourage you: take part. Think now about which friends, neighbors, or colleagues you’ll invite. Commit to hosting, even if you’ve never led a Shabbat dinner before. Let’s make Share Shabbat not just an idea but a movement — a chorus of open doors, full tables, and new friendships. Together, we can model a Judaism — and a society — of radical welcome and authentic relationship.

We are kicking off Share Shabbat on Friday night, October 24th with a special Shabbat dinner where we will explore how you can take part in this practice of welcome. Over the coming year, we’ll invite you to help us welcome others to experience Shabbat — both at Temple and in our homes — so they can encounter who we are through the practices and values that have shaped us for thousands of years.

We stand at a crossroads. We can remain caught in the cycle of fight, flight, and freeze — retreating behind our walls and closing ourselves off from the chance to form deep, life-giving relationships. Or we can choose another path: to light candles, open the ark, pass the challah, and welcome someone new. Each time we set a table instead of shutting a door, we can claim a different future — not only for ourselves, but for our community and our world.

May the One who makes peace on high teach us to make peace here below. May we practice the holy, countercultural, vulnerable and courageous work of opening our doors, our tables and our hearts. May the fear and noise of this moment not harden us, but instead awaken us to hospitality, to friendship, and to the steady practice of connection. May our homes become sanctuaries of welcome, and our Temple a beacon of trust, so that together we grow stronger and safer — as individuals, as a synagogue, as Jews, and as a society.

This new year may we choose open hands over clenched fists, connection over isolation, and hope over fear. And together we say: Amen.


Footnotes

1. “The State of Antisemitism in 2024,” American Jewish Committee, https://www.ajc.org/AntisemitismReport2024#prioritybox

2. Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg, On Repentance and Repair: Making Amends in an Unapologetic World (Boston: Beacon Press, 2022), 59.

3. State of Our City: Charlotte, “Christianity—Church,” https://charlotte.stateofourcity.com/en/realities/christianity-church.

Other Posts

Remembering October 7

Three years ago, October 7 entered Jewish memory on Shemini Atzeret and Simchat Torah, days of joy, gathering, and beginning again. We remember the people

Read More »

Beginning Again, Together

Every year on Simchat Torah, we reach the end of the Torah and immediately return to the beginning. The words have not changed. We have.

Read More »